• 13

A PHP Error was encountered

Severity: Notice

Message: Undefined index: userid

Filename: views/question.php

Line Number: 191


File: /home/prodcxja/public_html/questions/application/views/question.php
Line: 191
Function: _error_handler

File: /home/prodcxja/public_html/questions/application/controllers/Questions.php
Line: 433
Function: view

File: /home/prodcxja/public_html/questions/index.php
Line: 315
Function: require_once

I want to check my environment for the existence of a variable, say "FOO", in Python. For this purpose, I am using the os standard library. After reading the library's documentation, I have figured out 2 ways to achieve my goal:

Method 1:

if "FOO" in os.environ:

Method 2:

if os.getenv("FOO") is not None:

I would like to know which method, if either, is a good/preferred conditional and why.

      • 1
    • It is primarily opinion based. Both serve the same purpose. I will prefer method 1 as it is cleaner
      • 2
    • I can't say there's anything in it. Pick one (flip a coin?) and reevaluate later if it turns out not to work. Frankly I think you've spent more time typing this question than you'd save either way!
      • 1
    • @Ayoub: I think you forgot to see question "What is a good practice to check if an environmental variable exists or not in Python?"
    • Opinion based. Method 1 syntax serves better, since you ask if foo is in the env vars, not if seeking for foo results in None values.

Use the first; it directly tries to check if something is defined in environ. Though the second form works equally well, it's lacking semantically since you get a value back if it exists and only use it for a comparison.

You're trying to see if something is present in environ, why would you get just to compare it and then toss it away?

That's exactly what getenv does:

Get an environment variable, return None if it doesn't exist. The optional second argument can specify an alternate default.

(this also means your check could just be if getenv("FOO"))

you don't want to get it, you want to check for it's existence.

Either way, getenv is just a wrapper around environ.get but you don't see people checking for membership in mappings with:

from os import environ
if environ.get('Foo') is not None:

To summarize, use:

if "FOO" in os.environ:

if you just want to check for existence, while, use getenv("FOO") if you actually want to do something with the value you might get.

  • 168
Reply Report

There is a case for either solution, depending on what you want to do conditional on the existence of the environment variable.

Case 1

When you want to take different actions purely based on the existence of the environment variable, without caring for its value, the first solution is the best practice. It succinctly describes what you test for: is 'FOO' in the list of environment variables.

if 'KITTEN_ALLERGY' in os.environ:

Case 2

When you want to set a default value if the value is not defined in the environment variables the second solution is actually useful, though not in the form you wrote it:

server = os.getenv('MY_CAT_STREAMS', 'youtube.com')

or perhaps

server = os.environ.get('MY_CAT_STREAMS', 'youtube.com')

Note that if you have several options for your application you might want to look into ChainMap, which allows to merge multiple dicts based on keys. There is an example of this in the ChainMap documentation:

combined = ChainMap(command_line_args, os.environ, defaults)
  • 28
Reply Report

To be on the safe side use

os.getenv('FOO') or 'bar'

A corner case with the above answers is when the environment variable is set but is empty

For this special case you get

print(os.getenv('FOO', 'bar'))
# prints new line - though you expected `bar`


if "FOO" in os.environ:
    print("FOO is here")
# prints FOO is here - however its not

To avoid this just use or

os.getenv('FOO') or 'bar'

Then you get

print(os.getenv('FOO') or 'bar')
# bar

When do we have empty environment variables?

You forgot to set the value in the .env file

# .env

or exported as

$ export FOO=

or forgot to set it in settings.py

# settings.py
os.environ['FOO'] = ''

Update: if in doubt, check out these one-liners

>>> import os; os.environ['FOO'] = ''; print(os.getenv('FOO', 'bar'))

$ FOO= python -c "import os; print(os.getenv('FOO', 'bar'))"
  • 15
Reply Report

In case you want to check if multiple env variables are not set, you can do the following:

import os


    if var not in os.environ:
        raise EnvironmentError("Failed because {} is not set.".format(var))
  • 3
Reply Report

My comment might not be relevant to the tags given. However, I was lead to this page from my search. I was looking for similar check in R and I came up the following with the help of @hugovdbeg post. I hope it would be helpful for someone who is looking for similar solution in R

'USERNAME' %in% names(Sys.getenv())
  • -1
Reply Report

Trending Tags