• 9

A PHP Error was encountered

Severity: Notice

Message: Undefined index: userid

Filename: views/question.php

Line Number: 191


File: /home/prodcxja/public_html/questions/application/views/question.php
Line: 191
Function: _error_handler

File: /home/prodcxja/public_html/questions/application/controllers/Questions.php
Line: 433
Function: view

File: /home/prodcxja/public_html/questions/index.php
Line: 315
Function: require_once

name Punditsdkoslkdosdkoskdo

Combining node.js and Python

Node.js is a perfect match for our web project, but there are few computational tasks for which we would prefer Python. We also already have a Python code for them. We are highly concerned about speed, what is the most elegant way how to call a Python "worker" from node.js in an asynchronous non-blocking way?

This sounds like a scenario where zeroMQ would be a good fit. It's a messaging framework that's similar to using TCP or Unix sockets, but it's much more robust (http://zguide.zeromq.org/py:all)

There's a library that uses zeroMQ to provide a RPC framework that works pretty well. It's called zeroRPC (http://www.zerorpc.io/). Here's the hello world.

Python "Hello x" server:

import zerorpc

class HelloRPC(object):
    '''pass the method a name, it replies "Hello name!"'''
    def hello(self, name):
        return "Hello, {0}!".format(name)

def main():
    s = zerorpc.Server(HelloRPC())

if __name__ == "__main__" : main()

And the node.js client:

var zerorpc = require("zerorpc");

var client = new zerorpc.Client();
//calls the method on the python object
client.invoke("hello", "World", function(error, reply, streaming) {
        console.log("ERROR: ", error);

Or vice-versa, node.js server:

var zerorpc = require("zerorpc");

var server = new zerorpc.Server({
    hello: function(name, reply) {
        reply(null, "Hello, " + name, false);


And the python client

import zerorpc, sys

c = zerorpc.Client()
name = sys.argv[1] if len(sys.argv) > 1 else "dude"
print c.hello(name)
  • 119
Reply Report

For communication between node.js and Python server, I would use Unix sockets if both processes run on the same server and TCP/IP sockets otherwise. For marshaling protocol I would take JSON or protocol buffer. If threaded Python shows up to be a bottleneck, consider using Twisted Python, which provides the same event driven concurrency as do node.js.

If you feel adventurous, learn clojure (clojurescript, clojure-py) and you'll get the same language that runs and interoperates with existing code on Java, JavaScript (node.js included), CLR and Python. And you get superb marshalling protocol by simply using clojure data structures.

  • 86
Reply Report

If you arrange to have your Python worker in a separate process (either long-running server-type process or a spawned child on demand), your communication with it will be asynchronous on the node.js side. UNIX/TCP sockets and stdin/out/err communication are inherently async in node.

  • 7
Reply Report

I'd consider also Apache Thrift http://thrift.apache.org/

It can bridge between several programming languages, is highly efficient and has support for async or sync calls. See full features here http://thrift.apache.org/docs/features/

The multi language can be useful for future plans, for example if you later want to do part of the computational task in C++ it's very easy to do add it to the mix using Thrift.

  • 6
Reply Report

I've had a lot of success using thoonk.js along with thoonk.py. Thoonk leverages Redis (in-memory key-value store) to give you feed (think publish/subscribe), queue and job patterns for communication.

Why is this better than unix sockets or direct tcp sockets? Overall performance may be decreased a little, however Thoonk provides a really simple API that simplifies having to manually deal with a socket. Thoonk also helps make it really trivial to implement a distributed computing model that allows you to scale your python workers to increase performance, since you just spin up new instances of your python workers and connect them to the same redis server.

  • 5
Reply Report

I'd recommend using some work queue using, for example, the excellent Gearman, which will provide you with a great way to dispatch background jobs, and asynchronously get their result once they're processed.

The advantage of this, used heavily at Digg (among many others) is that it provides a strong, scalable and robust way to make workers in any language to speak with clients in any language.

  • 3
Reply Report

Update 2019

There are several ways to achieve this and here is the list in increasing order of complexity

  1. Python Shell, you will write streams to the python console and it will write back to you
  2. Redis Pub Sub, you can have a channel listening in Python while your node js publisher pushes data
  3. Websocket connection where Node acts as the client and Python acts as the server or vice-versa
  4. API connection with Express/Flask/Tornado etc working separately with an API endpoint exposed for the other to query

Approach 1 Python Shell Simplest approach

source.js file

const ps = require('python-shell')
// very important to add -u option since our python script runs infinitely
var options = {
    pythonPath: '/Users/zup/.local/share/virtualenvs/python_shell_test-TJN5lQez/bin/python',
    pythonOptions: ['-u'], // get print results in real-time
    // make sure you use an absolute path for scriptPath
    scriptPath: "./subscriber/",
    // args: ['value1', 'value2', 'value3'],
    mode: 'json'

const shell = new ps.PythonShell("destination.py", options);

function generateArray() {
    const list = []
    for (let i = 0; i < 1000; i++) {
        list.push(Math.random() * 1000)
    return list

setInterval(() => {
}, 1000);

shell.on("message", message => {

destination.py file

import datetime
import sys
import time
import numpy
import talib
import timeit
import json
import logging
logging.basicConfig(format='%(asctime)s : %(levelname)s : %(message)s', level=logging.INFO)

size = 1000
p = 100
o = numpy.random.random(size)
h = numpy.random.random(size)
l = numpy.random.random(size)
c = numpy.random.random(size)
v = numpy.random.random(size)

def get_indicators(values):
    # Return the RSI of the values sent from node.js
    numpy_values = numpy.array(values, dtype=numpy.double) 
    return talib.func.RSI(numpy_values, 14)

for line in sys.stdin:
    l = json.loads(line)
    # Without this step the output may not be immediately available in node

Notes: Make a folder called subscriber which is at the same level as source.js file and put destination.py inside it. Dont forget to change your virtualenv environment

  • 1
Reply Report

Trending Tags